This is a curated archive of scholarly opinions for educational purposes. SunnahAnswers indexes existing answers from qualified scholars — we do not issue rulings ourselves.

Answer 1 of 2Published work 1 min read
SourcePublished work
Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah· تقي الدين أحمد بن تيميةClassical Scholar

Majmū' al-Fatāwā

Majmū'' al-Fatāwā 11/535–576

The Four Imams of fiqh — Abu Hanifah, Malik, ash-Shafi''i, and Ahmad — are agreed that musical instruments (al-ma''azif) are forbidden. The proof is the explicit hadith of al-Bukhari (5590) on the authority of Abu Malik al-Ash''ari: the Prophet (ﷺ) said: "There will appear among my Ummah people who will declare permissible: fornication, silk, wine, and musical instruments (al-ma''azif)." The hadith establishes that ma''azif belong to the same category as fornication and wine — and the wording "will declare permissible" only makes sense if they were originally forbidden. Allah said: "And of the people are some who buy idle talk (lahw al-hadith) to mislead from the way of Allah." (Luqman 31:6) — Ibn Mas''ud said three times: "By Allah besides whom there is no god — it is singing." (al-Hakim, sahih). Excluded from the prohibition is: the duff (a one-sided drum) for women on weddings and at the two ''ids; the chants of the Companions while digging the trench; and the lullabies sung to children. Singing without instruments — if its words are clean and it is not a profession one habituates upon — is differed about, but the safest path is to leave it.

Key Takeaway

By the agreement of the Four Imams, musical instruments are haram — established by the explicit hadith in Bukhari grouping them with fornication and wine. Permitted: the duff for women at weddings, and clean a cappella in narrow settings.

Librarians, not Muftis

SunnahAnswers is a curated index of scholarly opinions — we collect, organize, translate, and present them. We do not author or rule. For binding rulings on your specific situation, consult a qualified scholar.

Ref: SA-0089 · Report an issue

More from Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah

More on this topic